On Tuesday, July 5, at 14:10 in Samara district Court Began to read the sentence with three Samara bloggers Dmitry Runner, Oleg Ivanta and Natalia Zvarova. They will remind them, accused of extorting a large amount of money from a businessman Sergei Shatilo. His own, by the way, in the hall there. Only his lawyer is present.
Breed the defendants bloggers
In the press hall and free listeners
Runner communicates with a lawyer
14:14 The judge reads the results of the investigation. Standard procedure: Transferring operational activities within this case.
14:18 Judge: "The defendants entered into a criminal conspiracy"
14:23 The judge says that bloggers put forward demand for Shatilo - 3 million rubles for the removal of compromising materials from the Blog of Ivanta.
14:28 The situation in the courtroom is tense: everyone stands, listen carefully. Running hot. Only Natalia Umäirova smiles and throws against the replicas with replicas with the Evan. The judge is also hot - it wipes his forehead from time to time.
14:42 The judge continues to read the sentence. There is no doubt that he is accusing.
Natalia Zemarova's husband (center) was depressed.
14:56 The judge reads how to delay Hyborg with money. In the hall unrealistic stuffy. The runner began to foam Natalia Leaf, so that she did not lose consciousness.
Recall how the detention was asleep and we. Here is the prompt video:
15:19 The court said that he believed the accusation of evidence was presented. "The words of the runner on providing pressure on him from the investigation - were not confirmed," the judge read.
15:30 The court does not believe the version with the provocation.
15:36 The court considers the guilt of bloggers in extortion of a particularly large amount of money by a group of persons on the preliminary conspiracy - completely proven. The reasons for the retraining of the article for the runner in the "fraud" servants of the femids do not see.
15:43 The court sentenced: Dmitry Runner to six years of the colony of a strict regime, Natalia Zhonarov - by five general mode, Ivanta - to seven years of strict regime. Penalties to pay, by the court decision, the figures will not be.
At the time of the sentence, the defendants were stone, irregularities.
15:51 Natalia Härova addresses her husband. She asks him to tell them a five-year-old daughter's truth: where her mother and for which she was punished.
15:53 \u200b\u200bDmitry Runner makes a statement that "business Shito white threads."
the most endless of the defendants is a convicted Oleg Ivana.
16:00 The state concretion has not yet been determined - whether the sentence will appeal.
16:01 Sergei's lawyer Shatilo Alexander Paulov said he intends to file to Dmitry Runner civil action. That he paid Sergey Shatilo moral compensation. Let me remind you that at that expense the court regretted the runner, regretted his children and canceled a fine of 500 thousand. But the side of the protection of the businessman in the right to submit a civil lawsuit.
16:15 Lawyer Ivanta stated that he would reach the European Court.
Thank you all for your attention. For you worked:
Dmitry Shiryaev (from the courtroom)
Natalia Shiryaeva (accepted, edited and issued information)
Interview Dmitry Runner for Samara Territory
Over the former Deputy Minister for Emergency Situations Dmitry Runner and Director of the Construction Firm Alexander Gritz. At the trial, it was announced, how they detained the defendants of the case.
Dmitry Runner
Former deputy minister They accused of obtaining a bribe of about 20 thousand dollars, director of the company - in the country of bribes and incitement to the country of bribes. In court it became known that late in the evening on March 19, Dmitry Runner was detained near his own house. He was handcuffed when a familiar businessman handed him in the car labeled bills.
In the spring of 2017, when the Customer has any problems with the commissioning of the building, Alexander Grits proposed to solve this problem through a friend Dmitry Runner, who, according to him, periodically gave bribes. The Deputy Minister of Emergencies agreed to help him promised 5 thousand dollars.
- On March 19, I met with the customer near the "Crown" on Calvarian, he handed me 5 thousand dollars, "Alexander Gritz says in court. - After 5 minutes, she was detained by the financial police, I was interviewed in the DFR, I myself showed the initiative and agreed to cooperation. I called the runner from my phone, offered to meet. At 11 pm, I drove up to his house, Dmitry Mikhailovich sat in the car, I opened the glove box where the money was lying. He took them and put them in the right jeans pocket.
- So why did you pass the money runner? - asked the prosecutor.
"For the fact that the factory Rochas closes his eyes to the observations of the inspector on the object," Alexander Gritz replied.
Due to the fact that the Grits is confused, remember only the election points, the court decided to read its testimony during the preliminary investigation.
"I suggested a runner of 5 thousand dollars, he agreed, wanted to spend this money on vacation in Goa," said Gritz on March 19 immediately after the arrest.
Alexander Grits. In court also read his words during the turnout that he was "partially repent." Then Grice pointed out that he passed 2 thousand dollars, he already announced 5 thousand dollars.
From the answers to the questions of lawyer Pavel Ivanyushev, it turned out that the director of the company had a salary of about 10 million, he was a rapid bribe from his own funds, mostly removed the salary from the card.
By the way, the Lithuanian businessman Arthur Turaev came to support Dmitry Runner. He passed the only one of all the defendants was released. It turned out, Turaev and the runner met in the SIZO in Volodarsky.
- I came literally for a few minutes. After all, people also supported me when the court was going, "Tut.by commented on Arthur Turaev.
In the court of the factory district of Minsk, a break was announced to the environment. Dmitry Runner has not yet expressed an opinion on the charges, clarifying that he had 3 days to familiarize with the materials of the criminal case, but he was ready for the process.
In the case of a former deputy minister for emergency situations Dmitry Runner. Together with him on the dock - director of a private enterprise Alexander Grits, who, according to the investigation, has repeatedly gave bribes to the official. For several years, the amount of about 20 thousand dollars got the amount. Now Colonel faces up to 15 years in prison.
Dmitry Runner
Alexander Grits.
Support their friends and relatives of the criminal case came to support. At the beginning of the process it turned out that Dmitry Runner Protect at once three lawyers, but from two he immediately refused.
For five months in the SIZO, a former official did not change much, at least externally. He did not hide from the lenses of cameras, calmly answered the court questions. Also led and Alexander Grits., former director private company "PM BRIGHTORATION". IN Single Registry Bankruptcy information is noted that the company is in the liquidation stage.
In court, Gritz said that he met the runner at the end of 2012, when he won the tender for repairs in the sports center, which is on the balance of Minsk City Municipal Emergencies Ministry. He headed the structure at that time Dmitry Runner.
Several companies sent applications, but am surprisingly, Grice was confident in his victory: even before declaring the results of the competition, he was reported that the competitors offered a higher price.
"Dmitry Mikhailovich asked:" Do you want to work with me? " - told Grits in court. - I understood, you need to offer something, because before that I was never invited to the office to the authorities before the conclusion of the contract. I wrote 3%. Dmitry Mikhailovich crumpled a piece of paper, shook my hand and said that everything would be fine. I myself identified the figure, by inner conviction. "
According to former director Firms, he transferred money to the official during the week after receipt of funds to the current account. Meets with a runner usually in the office, sometimes in the courtyard of his house, in in public places. The transfer of bribes of Grits tells everybody, special conspiracy, apparently, was not.
The total amount of bribes for several years amounted to about 20 thousand dollars. Typically, money was passed in Belarusian rubles. And only in the last episode - in foreign currency: 5 thousand dollars it was intended for the fact that he "Help close eyes" For violations of rules fire safety During the construction of a hundred on the street. On this official and caught, by the way.
The commissioning of the maintenance station was blocked by the fundamental inspector of the factory rofs. In the case file, there are documents for the ban on the construction for a period of six months. Such an option categorically did not suit the Customer, so he turned for help to the Grice: he knew that there was a connection in the ministry. The runner at that time was already deputy minister.
The official made that the object was passed on the papers at the end of 2016. 5 thousand dollars, although a rather big amount, but in case of delay, the customer of construction would have to pay about 20 thousand dollars to the budget.
Dmitry Runner decided the question, but the calculation was delayed with him. "Dmitry Mikhailovich was unhappy because he planned to spend this vacation money, - explained Grizza, referring to the fact that the bribe could not collect a service station for a long time. - Then the motivative failure came, the customer thought that his problems began, because he did not expect a runner. But I said that Dmitry Mikhailovich is a decent person, he would not go to this. "
In March, the Customer told Alexander Gritsa, which gathered the necessary amount. 5 thousand dollars official wanted to spend on holiday on Goa, reports Tut.BY. .
A few days later, the businessman brought money to the Deputy Minister: "Running to the house of the runner, offered to sit in my car. He opened the glove box, they lay there. He shifted them into the jeans pocket, did not recalculate. He said that the refusal to the object on the sewage can be thrown away. Promised that there would be no problems. "
In the case file, there is a video on which, according to the prosecutor Vadim Kisel, it can be seen how Alexander Gritz transfers a bribe to an official.
State Prosecutor Vadim Kisel
A few days after the arrest of the defendants, the situation with the deputy head of the Ministry of Emergency Situations commented Alexander Lukashenko.
"Bribe took. In place they took all- said the head of state. - All the same before the Law: Ministers, and Deputy Minister.
Lukashenko noticed that a former official did not accept objects with violations, but he instructed it with his subordinate.
"Deputy Minister, Great Man. What do you need, work. What do you miss? Shines eight years minimum(The runner was charged under Part 3 of Art. 430 of the Criminal Procedure, the article sanction provides for imprisonment from 5 to 15 years with confiscation of property. - Ed.). Improved the general position to spend time in prison, " - the president noted.
In court sounded that Dmitry Runner is a colonel of the internal service.
Former official refused to answer the question, whether he recognizes the guilt. "I could not familiarize yourself with the case material. I ask you to let me voice your position on charges at the dacha of the testimony, "- said Dmitry Runner.
Businessman Alexander Gritz said that he would recognize his guilt completely.
Photo of Sergey Balaily
Minsk, 16 Nov - Sputnik. The court of the factory district recognized the former Deputy Minister for Emergency Situations of Belarus Dmitry Runner guilty of obtaining bribes in a major amount and appointed him eight years in prison with serving a penalty in the reinforced regime colony. The .
The court also decided to consider the runner on the period of serving the sentence of detention from March 19, 2017.
Whiskey, rifle and bribe 5 thousand dollars
Also running the court appointed confiscation of property. 14.5 thousand Belarusian rubles, a car, a rifle, refrigerator, a few TVs, a few expensive handles of famous brands in packages, and a collection of expensive alcohol should be addressed to the state's income by decision of the factory district. In order to transfer the names of the famous brands of whiskey, brandy and vodka, which were withdrawn from the accused, the judge took a few minutes. In total, not less than 30 bottles were withdrawn.
© Sputnik / Anna Nefedova
By court decision, five thousand dollars (- Sputnik) will be "returned" to the Investigation Committee.
"Home Chemistry" for Gritsa
Equipment Runner Entrepreneur Alexander Gritz, who was detained with Runner, when he passed a bribe in the amount of five thousand dollars, was released from custody in the courtroom.
© Sputnik / Anna Nefedova
The court recognized him guilty of incitement to the country of bribes and appointed him five years restrictions on freedom without referral correctional institution. In addition, the court decided to remove the arrest with the property of Gritsa, and at the time of serving the sentence of detention from March 19, 2017, having counted the day for two.
Relatives and friends
At the announcement of the sentence, several dozen relatives and acquaintances of the accused came to the court of the factory district, they were mainly supporters of the runner. Going to the gym court sessionsThey began to make claims to journalists, throwing replicas that "the media perform someone's order." One of the women even declared referring to journalists: "You live on our taxes!".
© Sputnik / Anna Nefedova
Relatives and familiar Gritsa kept restrained. They waited when he came out of the courtroom, and went towards the department store "Belarus" with him, there was not far away the car in which they sat down.
Former Deputy Minister of Emergency Situations of Belarus Dmitry Runner sentenced to 8 years in prison with confiscation of property.
He is recognized as guilty of obtaining a bribe in particularly large amounts. As follows from the charge, the runner took a bribe repeatedly from May 2013 to March 2017. In particular, as the head of the Minsk City Governance (MSU) of the Ministry of Emergency Situations, during the 2013-2014 for about five receptions, he received from Gritsa as a bribe cash in the amount of at least BR90 million (before the denomination). It was about the trouble-free adoption by subordinate workers of the work performed and timely payment under the construction contract between Moscow State University and the RM BRIGHTORATOR, according to which construction and repair work was carried out at the address of the LogoSi tract, 17a.
In addition, he took bribes as a deputy minister for emergency. Knowing that work on the outer insulation of the building station building is suspended, gave an indication to the subordinate to assist in the trouble-free and speedy receipt of the positive conclusion of the expert council. As a result, in the shortest possible time were prepared required documents And a meeting of the Council was held with a positive result. For these actions, according to the court decision, in June-August 2016, the runner received money in two receptions - just not less BR4 thousand.
To readers have an idea of \u200b\u200bhow trial, we offer the report of "Belgazets" from the court sessions.
The Belarusian people did not swear
"He is rudely speaking, bursts for 15 years!" - Without hiding indignation, a former deputy minister for emergency situations Dmitry Runun, accused of obtaining bribes, spoke in court about his accommodation. And wrong. The position of the prosecutor in terms of punishment for the still colonel internal service has completely coincided with the opinion of the president.
In judicial testimony, former deputy minister of the Ministry of Emergency Situations Dmitry Runner stood on his accomplice - a businessman Alexander Gritsa: "He was a normal man, a man who always treated his parents, and to my family, and to me."
On November 9, the judicial investigation was completed in the court of the factory district of Minsk and passed the parties on the case of the former deputy head of the Emergencies Ministry Dmitry Runner.
The process began on September 5 chaired by Judge Zhanna Kuvenitsky, the state concluded supported Vadim Kisel. Figures of affairs are in custody are from March 19 T.G. The fact that the power suffered the loss of another official was the first in those spring days Alexander Lukashenko at the meeting in Mogilev with employees of Kronospan enterprises: "Bribe. In place they took all. What to be offended by me? All the same before the law: both ministers and deputy ministers. Improved to the general position in order to spend time in prison. Deputy Minister, Great Man. What do you need, work. What do you miss? " The most amazing thing is that Lukashenko looked like in the water. The investigation was only unwound, and he and the running time focused: "shines eight years at least."
It is so much in the debate of the parties asked for a colonel to the prosecutor - 8 years of the reinforced mode colony. Confiscation of property, deprivation of the title and the right to hold leadership positions is already an incatch. As with the civil lawsuit declared by the state procurement to the former deputy minister.
The runner is accused of receiving four bribes for the total amount of BYN23.9 thousand "For a favorable solution of issues included in its competence." The lawsuit declared for the amount of BYN14.5 thousand. As the prosecutor explained, this money was not discovered, they are unjust enrichment, and therefore are subject to recovery from the accused. The runner was detained with the Policy March 19 at the time of receiving $ 5 thousand from the Gritsa, the money was considered "discovered", and therefore they were deducted from the civil law.
As for the episodes, then, according to the prosecution, Colonel two bribes received in 2013-14., When he served as the head of the metropolitan department of the Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Ministry of Emergency Situations - BR90 million (non-denominated), in five techniques, and BR15 million in 2016-17. The rest - BYN 4 thousand (in two adhesives) and already mentioned $ 5 thousand. Money took for the solution of emerging problems in the Grice. Among them: assistance in concluding contracts for repair and construction and installation work at the objects of the Ministry of Emergency Situations and obtaining timely payment for the work performed, the trouble-free receipt of conclusions by fire supervision on various construction objects.
In the course judicial trial The state procurement has complaints about the indictment to Dmitry Runner, so he was presented with a new charge. Adjustment for the most part concerned the qualifying signs of the imputed episodes with the official position, which previously occupied the colonel.
He himself, during a re-interrogation, criticized the work of the prosecutor and recognized himself guilty only by the last episode, when it was taken with a political one, but "obviously not for the fact that I am imputed."
The speech in this episode for $ 5 thousand was that the Giritz customer had problems with obtaining a positive conclusion from the Inspector of the factory ROSC to commission the service station. According to the charges, the runner "took control" the situation and gave the instructions to the head of the district department to solve the problem.
The runner denies such a turn: "On January 30, an excited grit came to me and said that it was possible to earn it, it was then that the figure of $ 5 thousand was sounded for the fact that the Ministry of Emergency Situations of Minsk will give a positive conclusion. I understand that this is not my competence, I can not do anything, but at the same time knowing that the comments will be eliminated, the conclusion will still give me anyway and nothing needs to be done for this. I accepted this proposal, but I understood that I would not do anything for this, and did not. My attitude to the fact that I received $ 5 thousand was negative, I recognize the guilt and repent. "
Part of the runner's speech was dedicated to the nuances of his office activity. The accused, referring to the legislation, various departmental provisions and orders, denied that they were "actions against the interests of the service". Still Colonel stated that he was not a representative of the authorities, as noted in the accusation: "By holding the post of Deputy Minister, I only performed organizational and administrative duties and had no right to instruct instructions to persons."
The runner did not agree and with the fact that he was accused of committing a crime by a person who broke the oath. As it turned out, he did not swear to the Republic of Belarus. That's what he said about this: "I also charge me that I committed a crime in violation of me on October 31, 1990. The oath of the ordinary and the superior composition of the internal affairs bodies. I am accused of violation of the oath, which I took in another country. In the Ministry of Emergency Situations of Belarus I was not accepted. To date, I understand that I had to take the oath, which was approved by the President in 1999. Taking into account the activities that the Ministry of Emergency Situations are performed. In 1990, I was taking into account the oath, given the activities that the employees of the internal affairs bodies were performed, respectively (quoting): "In good faith and unquestionable to fulfill all the obligations assigned to me, without sparing their forces, but if necessary, When guarding conscientious public and state building, socialist property, rights of citizens and socialist law enforcement. " At the same time, it was not indicated in the accusation that the requirements of the USSR oath were violated.
Reference. September 11, 1998 Presidential Decree N442 The Ministry of Emergency Situations was reorganized by attaching to it allocated from the Military Movie fire service. January 19, 1999 The presidential decree was approved by the Regulations on the Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Republic of Belarus, in accordance with which functions were assigned to the Ministry of Emergency Situations government controlled in the field of warning and liquidation emergency situationsproviding fire safety.
The remaining episodes of receiving bribes Dmitry Runner denies. In this part, the accusation is based solely on the testimony of the Gritsa.
Prosecutor: - Do you think you are negotiated?
Runner: - Of course, negotiates.
Prosecutor: - And what are the motives in the Gritsa for the title?
Runner: - I was worried about the deed, apparently, he was promised to relax or free ... He wrote an obey appearance, four statements for liberation from custody, wanted to make a deal with a consequence. He wanted to get as little as possible. Analyze his testimony, and you will understand what fantasies it possesses. Knowing Gritsa, before he was here, it was a completely different person. What should happen in his head, after which he began to behave this way, then it is necessary to analyze what relationship we had before. He was a normal man, a word of a word, who always treated his parents, and to the family, and to me. But as we turned out to be here, he changed, I became an enemy of N1 for him. In connection with which? Let him ask him? He is me, roughly speaking, bursts for 15 years!
The lawyer Runner made an attempt to find out his attitude to a new charge in the Grice, but the judge took this question.
The businessman responded to other questions barely audible. He fully recognized his guilt. His prosecutor proposed to punish 5 years restrictions on freedom without referring to an open-type correctional institution.
Dmitry Runner was appointed Deputy Minister by Decree of the President in December 2015. According to the prosecution, at that time he was already involved in corruption. Moreover, at the general position turned out to be a person who did not swear to the Republic of Belarus and its people.