the principle of understandability is the representation of the goals, objectives, plans and the results of the activities of federal bodies executive power in the form that provides a simple and affordable perception by the Company of information on the activities of these authorities;
the principle of civil society involvement - ensuring the possibility of participation of citizens Russian Federation, public associations and the entrepreneurial community in the development and implementation of management decisions in order to take into account their opinions and priorities, as well as the creation of a system of continuous informing and dialogue;
the principle of accountability is the disclosure by the federal executive bodies of information on its activities, taking into account the requests and priorities of civil society, ensuring the possibility of the implementation by citizens, public associations and the entrepreneurial community of control over the activities of the federal executive bodies.
To comply with the principles of openness to federal executive authorities, the following tasks must be solved:
provide provision in understandable and affordable form of full and reliable information about the goals, objectives, plans for the activities of federal executive bodies for 2013-2018 and the course of their execution;
ensure fullness, accuracy, objectivity and timeliness of providing information on its activities to be disclosed in obligatory In accordance with the requirements of the legislation of the Russian Federation, provided at the requests of citizens of the Russian Federation, public associations and the entrepreneurial community;
improve the technology of granting and explaining information by expanding the methods and forms of its receipt by various users and groups of users, while ensuring the possibility of choosing a convenient format, accessibility, simplicity, understandability and visualization of the information provided;
increase the availability of open state data for the use of citizens, public associations and the entrepreneurial community, including for reuse, providing free access to the Internet information and telecommunications network (hereinafter - the Internet network) to open data contained in information systemsah federal executive bodies, without any restrictions on their secure use;
improve the processes of publication and infrastructure of the discovery of data, determining the priorities of their formation and disclosure, taking into account their value for society and the opening costs, including on the basis of feedback from users, detecting and spreading best practices for state data disclosure, improving the quality of published data, translating them in more convenient formats, adding descriptions (classification) and integrating (associated) data from different sets;
introduce processes and infrastructure, including electronic services and services, for public online consultations with citizens and organizations, as well as to implement online informs, maintenance and provision of information on the activities of the federal executive body, simultaneously simplifying ways of interaction with civil society;
ensure objectivity, imperfect and publicity of procedures for the formation of public, expert and advisory councils (commissions, working groups) created under the federal executive bodies, empower their necessary powers, take into account the opinion of these councils when making decisions;
to form and develop effective mechanisms for the operational response to the appeal of citizens of the Russian Federation, public associations and the entrepreneurial community are essentially set in questions about issues;
improve forms, methods and ways to work with the media, social networks and forums in the Internet.
IV. Mechanisms (tools) implementation of openness principles
The implementation of the principles of openness is carried out by applying the appropriate main mechanisms (tools), the continuous improvement of which will allow to implement the translational movement to ensuring the openness of the federal executive bodies. The main mechanisms (tools) of the implementation of the principles of openness of federal executive bodies (hereinafter referred to as the main mechanisms (tools) of openness) include:
implementation of the principle of information openness of the federal executive body;
ensuring work with open data;
ensuring the understanding of regulatory regulation, public policy and programs developed (implemented) by federal executive bodies;
adoption of the work plan and the annual public declaration of the goals and objectives of the federal executive bodies, their public discussion and expert support;
formation of public reporting of the federal executive body;
informing about working with appeals of citizens and organizations;
organization of work with reference groups;
interaction of the federal executive body with the Public Council;
organization of the work of the press service of the federal executive body;
organization of independent anti-corruption examination and public monitoring of law enforcement.
The mechanisms (tools) of openness are introduced by federal executive bodies, taking into account the methodological recommendations on the implementation of openness principles in the federal executive bodies, approved on December 26, 2013. The Government Commission for the Coordination of the Open Government Activities (hereinafter - the Commission).
The list of mechanisms (tools) of openness is not exhaustive and can be complemented in installed manner According to the results of generalization of the best practice in the field of openness government controlled, as well as at the discretion of federal executive bodies when implementing the principles of openness.
In order to ensure the effective implementation of the principles of openness and fulfilling the tasks of increasing the level of openness provided for by the concept, the federal executive bodies, taking into account the adopted regulatory legal acts and the decisions of the Commission, departmental plans for the implementation of the concept will be approved (hereinafter referred to as a departmental plan).
The departmental plans will determine the main directions in the field of increasing the openness of the federal executive bodies, activities aimed at improving openness (tools) of openness, specific targets for the effectiveness of their implementation, as well as responsible officials.
Executive plans will be approved by the heads of federal executive bodies and post on official websites in the Internet. Development of a departmental plan is carried out taking into account the results of monitoring the current state of the openness conducted in accordance with the methodology for monitoring and evaluating the openness of the federal executive bodies, approved by the Commission on December 26, 2013, and, if necessary, involving public Councilinterested in reference groups and experts.
V. System of monitoring and evaluation of openness of federal executive authorities
In order to inform the federal executive bodies, the Government of the Russian Federation and civil society about the progress of the concept of the concept of the concept of monitoring and evaluating the openness of the federal executive bodies, which includes:
self-examination (self-analysis) by federal executive authorities of the achieved results of the implementation and development of openness mechanisms (tools);
expert assessment of the effectiveness of the implementation by the federal executive authorities of the mechanisms (tools) of openness and compliance with their activities, the principles, goals and objectives provided for by the Concept;
sociological studies on the study of citizens' satisfaction and (or) reference groups by the level of openness of federal executive bodies.
Monitoring the openness of the federal executive bodies will be carried out by the Commission at least once a year in accordance with the methodology for monitoring and evaluating the openness of the federal executive bodies.
According to the results of such monitoring, the Minister of the Russian Federation, the Deputy Chairman of the Commission will submit to the Government of the Russian Federation an annual report on the openness of the federal executive bodies.
Vi. Resource Provision Implementation Concept
Resource ensuring the implementation of the Concept includes measures to regulate the methodological, information and analytical and personnel provision of its implementation, as well as work on improving the regulatory framework in the field of the formation of the "Open Government" system.
Regulatory and methodological support implies the development and adoption of regulatory and methodological and reference documents, including within the framework of the Commission's activities.
Informational and analytical support includes:
the organization and implementation of measures for public discusses, expert support, the exchange of best practices to increase the level of openness of federal executive authorities within the framework of the Commission's activities;
formation and development on the official website of the open government of information and analytical resources on the interactive submission of reports of federal executive bodies on the results of self-examination (self-analysis), as well as to create a "library of the best practice of the openness of the federal executive authorities".
Personnel provision provides:
the formation of a culture of the openness of the federal executive bodies, which is to ensure that any action taken as part of its daily activities maximizes the principles of openness;
determination of the federal executive authorities of the Deputy Head of the Federal Executive Authority, which is responsible for the implementation of the departmental plan and activities provided for by the Concept.
The implementation of the concept will be carried out by federal executive bodies within the framework of the established powers and budget allocations provided for by them by the Federal Law on the Federal Budget for the next fiscal year and the planning period for manual and management in the field of established functions.
Coordination of the activities of federal executive bodies in the implementation of the principles of openness will be carried out by the Commission.
|
Problem |
Decision |
|---|---|
|
The legislative list of information mandatory for disclosure (defined, in particular, in the methodological recommendations for openness and methods of its monitoring does not include the details of authority authority. Departmental development plans do not contain specific categories of information for posting on the site. At the same time, Some bodies there are no subordinate organizations, others, for example, work with limited access information. The user may not know about such specifics and to no avail to look for relevant information on the site, subsequently creating a flow stream. Therefore, there is a need to compare the specifics of the body and information disclosure requirements. |
The most effective solution is the creation of a legislative card - a list of subsections of the site with reference to the main categories of information to be accommodated, in accordance with Federal law 02/09/2009 №8-ФЗ "On ensuring access to information on the activities of bodies state power and organs local governments" If there are no grounds for posting certain categories of information, on a page with a legislative card you can place instructions for the absence of authority or units in the structure of the authority. In the presence of an approved departmental list of information in the map, a list of requirements of this regulatory act may be displayed. Unfortunately, at the federal level, this practice is not yet common. We recommend paying attention to progressive practices for the implementation of the legislative card functional at the regional level.
|
|
Experts offer the following solutions: 1. Identify the most popular information to be placed in HTML, and the subsequent consolidation of selection in departmental technological requirements for placing information or lists of information on activities published on sites. 2. Placing information in both HTML and file format. |
|
|
Often, the sites are published only by reference to general section federal resources ( http://zakupki.gov.ru/ , https://www.gosuslugi.ru/ , http://regulation.gov.ru/), not on the body profile page, a description of the procedure for providing a service or discussion of a specific bill. This greatly complicates the search for the user's need.
|
|
|
On the authorities sites there are practically no problems with the placement of short information (phone numbers, postal addresses, email addresses), however, when publishing volumetric materials (income information, inspection results, statistical information), there is often no integrity. Sometimes the results of the inspections are published only in the last year, income information is not posted for all officials.
|
When publishing large amounts of information, it is important to update information on time and save archived data. This allows the user to receive comprehensive information on this or that matter.
|
|
Thus, the new website of the Ministry of the Russian Federation on the Crimea affairs contains not enough information; The Ministry of the Russian Federation on the Affairs of the North Caucasus has no site. Many sections of the site Federal Agency Scientific organizations are in the stages of filling. It is worth noting that a number of other departments have similar problems with information openness: a number of other departments: the Federal Service for the Russian Federation, the Foreign Exterior Service of the Russian Federation, the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation, the General Directorate of Special Programs of the President of the Russian Federation.
|
To ensure an acceptable level of information openness, it is necessary to start creating an official site at the stage of formation of the department itself. |
Detailed information is available on clicking.
conclusions
The study of the information openness of official sites of the federal executive authorities revealed a number of positive trends:
Almost all sites published basic information (name of the state body, contact information, a description of the powers, functions, tasks, the structure of the state body).
Almost all sites correspond to the basic technical requirements (the correct operation of the site in popular browsers, the availability of a map of the official site, the presence on each page of the site of the main navigation menu);
Changes on the best design of sites: they gradually move to modern design and thoughtful design solutions.
Communication feeds are developing: most of the studied sites contain online feedback forms that allow you to quickly send the desired request / circulation.
A significant part of the authorities retained the positions occupied in a similar study of 2013. At the same time, the current rating clearly demonstrates the lack of efficiency of execution expanded regulatory requirements, as well as insufficient awareness of the procedure for posting information. Orientation for positive practices and attracting project experts for consultations can ensure a significant increase in the level of information openness of the sites of the federal executive bodies.
Examples of information placement on the site
Positive
In each subsection, you can get all relevant information: news, documents, announcements, media.
The site hosts an interactive map of the authorities with division into federal and territorial units, which simplifies navigation.
The site has a good version for the visually impaired, in which most sections are presented with the ability to choose a type of contrast.
Negative
Access to income information is limited to enter registration data (name, email address) and CAPTCHA. After that, a request is formed to the state agency, a response to which you need to wait (it is not known how soon he will come and will come at all).
Federal Protection Service (FSO.gov.ru)
The site design is not adapted for users with vision problems. It is also impossible to be called modern: there is no adaptive layout, the elements of the site are not dynamic.
Federal Space Agency (FederalSpace.ru)
Some sections have limited access without any references to regulatory legal acts that would be allowed.
Open data
The publication of information on the activities of the federal executive bodies in the format of open data is investigated by the Infiometer project for the second time. Previous audit was held in the period from December 2013 to February 2014. With the adoption of methodological recommendations, version 3.0, technological requirements for the publication of open data on the sites of the authorities have changed significantly. The process of adopting independent road maps to publish data arrays in machine-readable formats intensified.
Top 10 and antiting
It should be noted that despite the inclusion in anti-raid, a number of authorities actively worked on the placement of open data and significantly improved the initial indicators. So, actively interacted with experts and ensured the increase in openness of 14.38%
We hope that further work on improving the "Open Data" section will allow Rosrestera to significantly strengthen its position in the ranking of openness.
The level of openness of individual categories of information
Openness in numbers
224 Set Published from 399 Mandatory for publication by order of the Government of the Russian Federation of July 10, 2013 No. 1187-p. According to this document, the executive authorities should be postponed by the Government of the Russian Federation 7 Mandatory datasets.
Federal Service for Transport Supervision
Federal Agency of Scientific Organizations
Federal Youth Agency
Federal Agency for the Commonwealth of Independent States, Compatriots living Abroad and International Humanitarian Cooperation
Foreign Intelligence Service of the Russian Federation
Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation
Federal Protection Service of the Russian Federation
Main Department of Special Programs of the President of the Russian Federation
Ministry of Russian Federation for Crimea
Ministry of the Russian Federation on the Affairs of the North Caucasus
Ministry of the Russian Federation for the Development of the Far East
Federal Space Agency
placed more than 100 sets of open data
Federal Agency for Tourism
Federal State Statistics Service
placed more than 50 sets of open data
federal Service state registration, inventory and cartography
Federal Alcoholic Market Regulatory Service
placed more than 10 sets of open data
Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation
Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation
Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation
Ministry of Industry and Trade of the Russian Federation
Ministry of Communications I. mass communications Russian Federation
Ministry of Construction and Housing and Communal Services of the Russian Federation
Ministry of Labor I. social protection Russian Federation
Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation
Ministry economic Development Russian Federation
Federal Antimonopoly Service
The Federal Migration Service
The Federal Tax Service
Federal Accreditation Service
Federal Environmental Supervision Service
Federal Service for Supervision in Communication information technologies and mass communications
Federal Tariff Service
Federal Service for Technical and Export Control
Federal Service of the Russian Federation for Drug Traffic Control ( federal Service)
Federal Customs Service
Federal Air Transport Agency
Federal Maritime and River Transport Agency
Federal Agency for State Reserves
Federal State Property Management Agency
Federal Road Agency
Federal Treasury (Federal Service)
· Www.yandex.ru.
· www.roselecom.ru.
· Www.google.com.
Where are the open data government agencies?
· On the official websites of state bodies in the Internet "Internet"
· On the official website of the President of the Russian Federation
· In the federal state information system " Federal portal Public service and management personnel "
· on the portal of the open data of the Russian Federation
What type of file is the source to transfer it to the CSV format?
· Excel
How many levels of openness in federal executive authorities?
Which item must click to view the volume of the installed RAM computer's operational memory?
What element must be needed to change the keyboard language?
What keys are used to create a snapshot of the active window?
· ALT + PRINT SCREEN
· Ctrl + Insert
Click the title string shown below the window?
What button must be pressed to increase the size of the open window?
How does the selected file relate to the selected folder?
· The selected folder and the dedicated file are on the same level.
· The selected file is in the selected folder.
· The selected file contains the selected folder.
· Selected file and selected folder are in different places
681. With which tab you can call a command Properties To determine the size of the selected folder?
With which tab, you can change the view of the selected folder so that the folder contents look like on the bottom figure?
683. What is the command in the menu Arrange Allows you to determine the size of the selected folder?
684. What button you need to click to access the command Completion of work?
You want the text to have an indentation of the first line of each paragraph by 1.25 cm. What button do you need to click to invoke the corresponding dialog box?
You want the firmist interval 2 of the text paragraph to be a similar larrred interval of 1 paragraph of text and accounted for exactly 22 PTs. What button must be pressed to call the corresponding dialog box?
You want the firmist interval of 2 paragraph of text to be a similar larrred interval of 1 paragraph of text and amounted to 22 PT. What sequence of actions in the dialog box will allow you to get this result?
· Will lead in field 1 value "12", then enter the value "12" in field 2 and click on the button OK
· Click on the field 3 and select the command For sure Then in the field 4, enter a value 22 and click the button OK
Methodik
Monitoring and evaluation of openness
Federal executive bodies
I. General provisions
Monitoring and evaluation of the executive power (hereinafter - monitoring openness) is held with the aim of informing the federal executive bodies, the Government of the Russian Federation and civil society about the implementation of the concept of openness of the federal executive bodies (hereinafter - the concept of openness).
Monitoring of openness is carried out by the decision of the Government Commission for the Coordination of the Open Government's activities (hereinafter - the Government Commission) at least once a year.
The object of monitoring of openness is the results of the activities of federal executive bodies on the implementation of the principles of openness and implementation in their activities of openness (tools) of openness.
Basic methods for monitoring openness:
a) self-examination (self-analysis) by federal executive bodies of the achieved results for the implementation and development of openness mechanisms (tools);
b) expert assessment of the effectiveness of the implementation by federal executive authorities of the mechanisms (tools) of openness and compliance with their activities, the principles, goals and tasks of openness, approved by the concept of openness (hereinafter referred to as expert assessment);
c) Sociological studies on the study of the level of confidence and satisfaction of citizens, public associations and the entrepreneurial community by the level of openness of the federal executive bodies.
II. Self-examination
federal executive bodies
Self-examination The federal executive authorities are carried out on each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness provided for by the concept of openness:
1) the implementation of the principle of information openness of the federal executive authority;
2) ensuring work with open data;
3) ensuring the comprehension of regulatory regulation, state policies and programs developed (implemented) by federal executive bodies;
4) adoption of plans for the activities of federal executive bodies for the period 2013 - 2018. and the annual public declaration of goals and objectives; their public discussion and expert accompaniment;
5) the formation of reporting of the federal executive body;
6) informing about working with the appeals of citizens and organizations;
7) organization of work with reference groups of the federal executive body;
8) the interaction of the federal executive body with the Public Council;
9) the work of the press service of the federal executive body;
10) Organization of independent anti-corruption examination and public monitoring of law enforcement.
The list of openness mechanisms (tools) is not closed and can be complemented as the principles of openness are implemented by federal executive bodies, as well as taking into account the priorities in the field of openness and publicity established by the Government of the Russian Federation, the Government Commission in accordance with the expectations and requests of civil society.
Evaluation of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness (hereinafter - the implementation of the implementation) is carried out by federal executive bodies by self-examination (self-analysis) separately in terms of development of openness mechanisms (tools) in accordance with the form for self-examination approved in Appendix N 1 to the methodology and In terms of performance of the operations of the mechanisms (tools) of openness, approved in Annex N 2 to the methodology.
The introduction of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness implies the presence of 3 stages of development of the openness mechanism (tool) in the activities of the federal executive authorities (hereinafter referred to as stage), which reflect the sequential formation and improvement of the specific mechanism (tool) of openness.
Indicators of development of openness mechanisms (tools) (hereinafter referred to as development indicators), distributed in three stages, can be taken into account by federal executive authorities in the development and approval of departmental plans (road maps) implementation of the principles of openness in their activities.
Performance of the development indicators of the first stage is mandatory for the implementation of each opening mechanism (tool), since they are established on the basis of the requirements of regulatory legal acts. The development indicators of the second stage reflect the dynamics of formation and use of the mechanisms (tools) of openness in the activities of federal executive bodies. At the third stage, development indicators take into account the use of the federal executive authority to improve the work of the mechanisms (tools) of the openness of web technologies.
All development rates on each of the three stages for all mechanisms (tools) of openness are estimated on a nominal scale: on the fact of the presence or absence of value and (or) on the fact of formal compliance, "there is no". The value of the development indicator is taken equal to zero in the event of an answer in the assessment of the introduction of "no", equal to one - "partially yes, partially no", equal to two - "yes."
The implementation of the implementation is calculated by the federal executive bodies by summing the values \u200b\u200bof development indicators for each of the three stages separately. Based on the fact that in order to introduce each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness, performing indicators of development of the first stage is mandatory, 0.1 on the sum of the values \u200b\u200bof the development indicators of the first stage are taken as the value of the coefficient in summing the development indicators in the second and third stages.
The resulting evaluation estimate for each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness is calculated by the formula:
The sum of the values \u200b\u200bof development indicators in the first stage,
The sum of the values \u200b\u200bof development indicators in the second stage,
The sum of the values \u200b\u200bof development indicators in the third stage.
In order to assess the results and dynamics of the implementation of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness, indicators of the performance of openness mechanisms (tools) are established (hereinafter referred to as performance indicators).
Upon reaching the mechanism (tool) of the openness by all federal executive authorities, the sum of the values \u200b\u200bof the development indicators of the first stage equal to 10, the development indicators of this stage are abolished, and instead of them, by decision of the Government Commission, a new performance indicator is added. Analogically, the Government Commission is a decision on the abolition of development indicators in the second and third stages, respectively.
The values \u200b\u200bof performance indicators are calculated by federal executive bodies based on statistical indicators approved in Appendix N 2 to the methodology, and is expressed as a percentage.
Evaluation of performance for each mechanism (tool) of openness is calculated by the formula:
The final assessment of the effectiveness of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness,
x - the number of opened mechanisms (tools) created by the federal authority of the executive
R - the value of the performance indicator, expressed as a percentage,
n - the number of performance indicators.
The value of the integral indicator of the implementation of the mechanism (tool) created by the federal authority of the executive authority is calculated by the formula:
The resulting evaluation of the implementation of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness,
The final assessment of the effectiveness of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness /
x - the number of opened mechanisms (tools) created by the federal authority of the executive authority.
The results of self-examination The federal executive authorities submit to the Government Commission to form a common ranking of the openness of the federal executive bodies. The results of self-examination are also subject to the public resource of the "Open Government" system.
III. Conducting expert assessment
An expert assessment is carried out in two directions: an expert assessment of the effectiveness of specific mechanisms (tools) of openness and expert assessment of the effectiveness of the implementation of the principles of openness by federal executive bodies.
As the source data, the values \u200b\u200bof integral indicators of implementation, calculated by the federal executive authorities for each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness on self-examination, are used as source data.
An expert assessment is carried out by an unlimited range of experts, the procedure for attracting which is determined by the Government Commission.
Experts assess the efficiency of openness mechanisms (tools), taking into account the following basic efficiency criteria:
orientation of the operation of the mechanism (tool) of openness at the end user (including on reference groups, citizens, public associations, etc.),
the involvement of the expert community and public associations in the work of the openness mechanism (tool) and its relevance,
transparency of the work of the mechanism (tool) of openness.
An expert assessment of the performance of the mechanisms (tools) of the openness of federal executive authorities is carried out by each expert on a 10-point score scale, where:
points from 1 to 3 mean the formal creation of a mechanism (tool) of openness, which is incomprehensible, uninteresting, not in demand by civil society and simulates the openness of the federal executive body;
points 4 - 5 - the low quality of the work of the mechanism (tool) of openness, which is in demand by a fairly narrow expert community, the significant results of its work are practically absent and (or) are unknown;
points 6 - 7 - the average quality of work of the openness mechanism (tool), the results of its work are not demanded enough in a broad expert community and citizens, but already have a positive experience in the interests of representatives of reference groups and public associations;
points from 8 to 10 - the effective and qualitative work of the mechanism (tool) of openness, contributing to the implementation of the principles of openness in the activities of federal executive bodies.
The final expert assessment of effectiveness is calculated for each mechanism (tool) of openness by the formula:
,
Expert evaluation of the performance of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness,
x - the number of opened mechanisms (tools) created by the federal authority of the executive
Evaluation of each expert on the mechanism (instrument) of openness;
n is the number of experts participating in the expert assessment.
Expert assessment of the effectiveness of the implementation by the federal executive authorities of the principles of openness is carried out by members of the Government Commission, members of the Expert Council under the Government of the Russian Federation, members Public Chamber Russian Federation, public councils under the federal executive bodies, media representatives, other organizations and citizens by decision of the Government Commission.
The results of official monitoring, which in accordance with the established procedure, conduct authorized federal executive bodies on individual mechanisms (instruments) of openness, are taken into account as special indicators of the expert assessment of the effectiveness of the openness mechanism (tool) when calculating the openness index of federal executive bodies (hereinafter referred to as the openness index). By decision of the Government Commission, the results of independent monitoring carried out by public associations may also be taken into account.
IV. Calculation of the openness index and the formation of the rating
federal executive bodies
According to the results of monitoring of openness, the openness index is calculated, which, on the basis of a single approach to the estimation of the openness of the federal authorities, allows us to form a general ranking of the openness of the federal executive bodies.
At the initial stage of monitoring openness, the openness index is determined by summing up the values \u200b\u200bof openness indicators obtained for each federal executive body, according to the formula:
O - openness index,
Integral indicator of the introduction of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness,
The final expert assessment of the performance of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness,
x - the number of opened mechanisms (tools) created by the federal authority of the executive
M - the results of monitoring the expert assessment of the efficiency of the mechanism (tool) of openness, expressed as a percentage in accordance with the established estimation scale,
n - Number of monitors of the expert assessment of the effectiveness of the mechanism (tool) of openness.
The ranking of the openness of the federal executive bodies is calculated by experts in the framework of assessing the effectiveness of the implementation by federal executive authorities of the principles of openness and takes into account all the results of monitoring openness, including the federal executive bodies obtained during the self-examination), including:
the values \u200b\u200bof integral indicators of the implementation of openness mechanisms (tools),
the values \u200b\u200bof the final expert assessment of the efficiency of the operations (tools) of openness,
openness index
assessment of additional initiatives of the federal executive body aimed at implementing the principles of openness,
consideration of the activities of federal executive bodies from the point of view of the success of the implementation of adopted departmental plans to increase the level of openness and the implementation of the mechanisms (tools) of openness and so on.
In addition, the ranking of openness should take into account expert assessment of the level of public participation, reflecting the involvement of citizens, public associations and the entrepreneurial community into the processes of development, adoption, implementation, monitoring and revising decisions taken by the federal executive authority.
The openness rating of the federal executive authorities is to attribute the activities of the federal executive body to introduce the principles of openness to one of the following levels of openness: 1st level - preparatory, 2nd level - starter, 3rd level - basic, 4- th level - advanced.
The preparatory level of openness is assigned to federal executive bodies, in which:
the resulting assessment of the implementation of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness does not exceed 4.9 points;
serious problems have been identified with the fulfillment of the requirements of current legislation in terms of the implementation of most instruments (mechanisms) of openness;
in the activities of the federal executive body, not all mechanisms (tools) of openness are being introduced, the implementation of some of them has a simulation nature;
there is no dynamics of performance indicators;
the final expert assessment of the effectiveness of each mechanism (tool) of openness does not exceed 3 points;
a low level of public participation, which usually consists of one-sided provision of information from the federal executive body and in which no interaction or involvement of civil society institutions in the development and decision-making process is not required.
The starting level of openness is assigned to federal executive bodies in which:
the resulting assessment of the implementation of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness from 5 to 14.9 points;
in the activities of the federal executive body, all mechanisms (tools) of openness are introduced, established by the concept of openness, but some of them are implemented formally;
all indicators of the development of the first stage in most of the mechanisms (tools) of openness are achieved;
at least five mechanisms (tools) of openness have the positive dynamics of performance indicators;
final expert assessment of the effectiveness of each mechanism (tool) of openness from 4 to 5 points;
the federal executive bodies request the public and experts on their opinions on a particular topic or policy development, while consulting, as a rule, include informing the Company from the federal executive bodies on the changes in policies and requests for comments, opinions and reactions. The initiative and themes predominantly proceed from the federal executive bodies, and not from representatives of public associations and experts.
The basic level of openness is assigned to federal executive bodies, in which:
the resulting assessment of the implementation of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness from 15 to 20 points;
all indicators of the development of the first stage in all mechanisms (tools) of openness are achieved;
technological solutions are developed and introduced, aimed at improving the efficiency of individual mechanisms (tools) of openness;
all mechanisms (tools) of openness have a positive dynamics of performance indicators;
the final expert assessment of the effectiveness of each mechanism (tool) of openness from 6 to 7 points;
the federal executive body implements 1 - 2 additional initiatives to implement the principles of openness in their activities periodically conducts seminars for its employees to introduce openness;
the main form of public participation is a dialogue, the initiative of entry into which can come from any side: it can be either wide or in the spirit of cooperation. A wide dialogue is bilateral communication, built on mutual interests and potentially common tasks to ensure regular exchange of views - from open public hearings to specialized meetings between citizens, representatives of public associations, the entrepreneurial community and the federal executive authorities. The dialogue in the spirit of cooperation is carried out on a wide range of issues and is built on mutual interests regarding the specific policy development and, as a rule, leads to the nomination of joint recommendations, strategies or projects of regulatory legal acts.
Advanced opening level is assigned to federal executive bodies, in which:
the resulting estimate of the implementation of each of the mechanisms (tools) of openness from 21 to 30 points;
in the activities of the federal executive authority, all mechanisms (tools) of openness are introduced;
all development rates have been achieved in the first stage and most of the development indicators in the second and third stages in all mechanisms (instruments) of openness;
technological solutions are developed and introduced, aimed at improving the efficiency of all the mechanisms (tools) of openness;
according to most of the mechanisms (tools) of openness, high values \u200b\u200bof expert performance indicators have been achieved, which have a positive growth dynamics;
the final expert assessment of the effectiveness of each mechanism (tool) of openness from 8 to 10 points;
the federal executive body implements several additional initiatives to implement the principles of openness in its activities, periodically conducts seminars on the implementation of openness not only for its employees, but also for all interested reference groups;
public participation is based on a partnership and implies mutual responsibility at each stage of the process of making joint decisions: project development, preparation, adoption and implementation of decisions.
By decision of the Government Commission, the openness of the federal executive body determined by experts can be elevated or lowered on the basis of the consideration of an independent expert co-collage prepared with the participation of the Expert Council under the Government of the Russian Federation, the Public Chamber of the Russian Federation, other public associations and the entrepreneurial community.
When calculating the ranking of openness of federal executive bodies, the results of sociological research on the study of the level of confidence and satisfaction of citizens, public associations and the entrepreneurial community by the level of openness of federal executive bodies are considered.
V. Final provisions
By decision of the Government Commission, the results of sociological studies provided for by this technique may be included in the calculation of the openness index. From January 1, 2015, weight coefficients reflecting priorities and (or) significance of each of them can be introduced for openness index, which reflects the priorities and (or) significance of each of them to calculate the openness index during the monitoring of openness.
According to the results of monitoring the openness of federal executive bodies, the Minister of the Russian Federation submits to the Government of the Russian Federation an annual report on the openness of the federal executive bodies.
The list of information that in accordance with the development rates of federal executive bodies during self-examination must be placed on official websites in the Internet information and telecommunication network, is mandatory on the basis of paragraph 56 of the list of information on the activities of the federal executive bodies, the management of the activities of which carry out The Government of the Russian Federation, and the federal executive bodies, posted on the Internet, approved decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of November 24, 2009 N 953.
Appendix N 1.
Openness of federal bodies
executive power
Shape for self-examination
With indicators of mechanisms
(Tools) openness
Adopted in the text abbreviation
| Openness mechanism (tool) | Stage 1. | Stage 2. | Stage 3. | Implementation of the principle of information openness | 1. Approved and posted on the site FOOV departmental order (regulations, rules), ensuring access and disclosure of publicly available information in accordance with the principles of openness. | 1. On the FOB website, a full-text search system and search for metadata is implemented (for example, on document attributes). | 1. The site contains auxiliary videos, presentations, advantageous advantages of interaction with the Office on the Internet | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. On the site FOOV published a closed list of information about the activities of the FOOV, access to which is limited by federal legislation, indicating the NPA details, in accordance with which this restriction is established, and all possible cases of Foiv refusal in providing information to the applicant, access to which federal laws. | 2. Foiv organizes the placement of information on the activities of subordinate organizations on their sites in accordance with the requirements of the law N 8-FZ. On the FOB website, the necessary links to the sites of the subordinate organizations are indicated. | 2. On the Foive website there are mobile services available for downloading users who allow you to receive freight services and share the site contents of the FOB through smartphones. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. The version of the site has been running for people with disabilities. | 3. In the premises occupied, the rooms are installed technical means, incl. Computers and tablet devices with access to the Official Site Foiv to provide information on the activities of the FOOV, the request for the provision of public services in electronic form, etc. | 3. The content of the FOB site is available on different devices and in all screen permissions, while the detection speed of the required information does not depend on the on-screen resolution or the device used. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. On the FOB website, the rules and conditions for using the content of the site are posted. | 4. The FOB website has been implemented by functionality, which allows to evaluate the effectiveness of stay and work of citizens with the FOB site, including indicators: attendance, time of stay, the popularity of individual sections of the site, the depth of viewing. | 4. On the Foive website, interactive services are posted: online advice, visitors, voting polls, electronic forms for appeals, discussion platforms, etc. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. APPROVED, published on the FOOV website and is accessible to the discussion of the strategic (conceptual) plan for the development of the FOB site. | 5. On the FOB website implemented the opportunity for citizens in interactive mode to evaluate the usefulness of the information posted on the site and provided upon request using the valuation variative scale. | 5. The FOB website has been implemented online dialogue with citizens to collect proposals for improving the tools, the rules of work and the content of the FOB site. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 1. All mandatory data sets are published in accordance with the requirements of the Law N 8-FZ and the Resolution No. 953. | 1. Published in open data format All reference books that are filed by FOB according to information from Unified system regulatory information (http://nsi.gosuslugi.ru/_layouts/nsiinfrastructure/welcomepage.aspx). | 1. In the new information systems created, as well as the TK on the revision of current information systems, an automatic unloading function on the data site in the outdoor data formats is provided. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. The data in the format of open data is published in accordance with the requirements. methodical recommendationsdeveloped by the Ministry of Economic Development of Russia and approved by the Government Commission. | 2. Evaluation of the demand for data sets, potential for disclosure. | 2. There are regular events with application developers based on open data. FOOV (meetings, seminars). | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. Audit was carried out information resources Foiv in order to identify potentially ready to publish data sets. Results are published in open access. | 3. Storage of past versions of open data sets is organized. | 3. The process of correcting actual errors in the data and clarification by feedback is organized. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. Appointed official representative of the FOOV, responsible for the work in the opening of state data. | 4. Society requests, incl. In the individual of the media, the reference groups on the data are taken into account when determining the priorities of the publication of data. | 4. Data is published in the associated data format (LINKED DATA) using RDF / OWL models, 5 stars on the W3C scale. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. Data sets identified by the audit of the Agency's information resources were discussed on the Open Data Council under the Government Commission for the Coordination of the Open Government. | 5. FOOV representatives involved in working with open data were trained in major competencies. | 5. The data is published in accordance with the Decree of the Government of Russia of September 14, 2012 N 928. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 1. On the Foive website is located and updated the schedule. regulatory work for a year. | 1. A plan-schedule of regulatory work on the medium and long term with a description of the problems to be resolved with the adoption of NAP, discussed with the Public Council, expert and advisory groups with Foiv. Information is posted on the site. | 1. Foiv attracts an open expert community to the assessment and examination of the NPA project, as well as a public assessment through crowdsourcing mechanisms. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. FOOV posts on the site Study (analysis), which contains a description of the problem requiring regulatory regulation, the purpose of acceptance legal Act, explains the impact of the NPA project on the lives of citizens and its relationship with the current NPA on an understandable and affordable language. | 2. FOOV holds media skipping on the information coverage of the development of a socially significant project of NPA and (or) its concept. | 2. FOOV is provided for the procedure for explaining the NAP using elements of infographics, videos, formatting and representing the Fragments of the NPA text in a visual and understandable form. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. Foiv prepares and distributes brochures (booklets) with a description of the current regulatory regulation, with schemes and infographics, answers to frequently asked questions - in paper and electronic form. | 3. For public discussion of the project, the NPA is being developed and posted on the site by turning explanatory materials (taking into account the clearness of the language and styles of presentation), an alternative, understandable text presentation of the NPA project, comments, infographics. | 3. FOOV periodically conducts webinars, video conferencing, discussion tables and other public events in which interested persons can ask questions on regulatory legal regulation and (or) law enforcement practice in the field of Poor's authority. Information is posted on the site. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. The FOB website created structured by topics and tags (keywords), with the possibility of extended thematic search, a section with reference information on the existing legal regulation in the field of powers | 4. Foiv keeps work on promoting legal and professional knowledge in the field of Poor Powers, incl. In the media, the Internet and social networks, creates training materials (presentations, booklets, video materials). | 4. FOOVE places on the site views, reviews, recommendations of experts, citizens, the leadership of FOOV in the form of rollers, news texts, links for discussion on social networks, a blogosphere, other relevant platforms. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. The FOB website contains thematically selected and understandable information containing all the rules (requirements), which establishes and (or) controls the FOB (including, requirements, compliance (execution) is the subject of the forage of the control checks) | 5. FOOV periodically conducts webinars, video conferencing, discussion tables and other public events in which interested persons can ask questions on regulatory and legal regulation and (or) law enforcement practice in the field of Poiv authority. | 5. Section of the site with reference information on the existing legal regulation in the field of POWD authority is complemented by infographics, step-by-step algorithms of actions with descriptions of permits and other procedures. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | Adoption of FOOV activities for the period 2013 - 2018. and the annual public declaration of goals and objectives; their public discussion and expert support | 1. Public Declaration // Public Plan reflects the plans for FOOV to achieve target indicators approved by the Decrees of the President of the Russian Federation. | 1. The tree of goals and objectives is described, which reflects the distribution of personal responsibility between the leadership of the FOOB for achieving the goals, objectives and results of the public declaration // Public Plan. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 1. For each of the established goals, tasks, key events and indicators in interactive mode, you can receive topical information about the current execution, including statistics, references to documents, quotes from the media, interviews, examples of the best practice, videos. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. A system of discussion of a public declaration is organized // Public Plan with Public Council, reference groups, expert and advisory bodies with Foiv. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 2. A system for collecting comments and evaluations of stakeholders based on the results of public discussion of the public declaration is published // Public Plan. | 2. Approved the procedure for adjusting the public declaration // Public Plan based on the results of public discussions. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. Goals, tasks, key events and measurement indicators are formulated in a public declaration // Public Plan on a language understandable and accessible to citizens. | 3. FOOV is analyzing and summarizing the comments of the results of the public declaration // Public Plan. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 3. Foiv prepares analytical notes (certificates) based on public discussion of the results of the execution of a public declaration // Public Plan. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. Developed the procedure for public discussion of the results of the fulfillment of the FOOB obligations in the public declaration // Public Plan. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 4. Targets are indicated in comparison with the indicators for previous periods. | 4. MediaKames are carried out on the coverage of public discussion of the results of the fulfillment of the Communications of the FOOB from the Public Declaration // Public Plan. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. FOOV is a submission of a public declaration. within panel discussions with citizens, press conferences, etc. | 5. A continuous discussion of the dynamics of achieving the goals, objectives and indicators established in the public declaration is maintained // Public Plan, with the Public Council, reference groups, expert and advisory bodies with Foiv, other stakeholders. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 5. Dynamics of achieving goals, tasks, key events and indicators established in a public declaration // Public Plan, visualized on the FOB website, taking into account the interests of different reference groups. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | Foil reporting formation | 1. On the Foiv website there is a schedule of state procurement, including works on Nir and R & D. | 1. In Foiv developed order public control Citizens and community associations and associations legal entities Observice in the forage of the legislation of the Russian Federation and other regulatory legal acts on the contract system in the field of procurement. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 1. On the Foive website there is a report on procurement activities in accordance with the schedule plan, including information on the progress of the state order, the average number of participants, the percentage of savings, etc. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. On the Foiv website there is information containing: - NPU details on approval of all departmental, state, federal targeted programs, whose executor is Foiv; - FULL NAME and contact information about responsible performers for each program in Foiv; - the deadlines for the start and end of the implementation of programs, if there are plans for the implementation of program activities; - Expected results of program implementation. | 2. The FOOV website hosts information on the implementation of plans and programs in the context: - achievements established under the reporting periods of indicators (performed measures), - distribution budget funds According to relevant activities (indicators), the state procurement for the implementation of the planned activities. | 2. On the FOB website provides information on the expenditure of allocations federal budgetstipulated by the freight to ensure the execution of its functions, including information: - expenditure obligations and income formulation, - the distribution of costs for goals, objectives and programs, - the effectiveness of budget expenditures, - monthly reports on FOOV costs for their own needs. | 0 - no; 0.5 - for each of the listed positions. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 0.5 - there is in general form, 0.5 - for each of the listed positions. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. The following information is available on the FOB website: - statistical and analytical data on the receipt of civil service; - quarterly reports on received and reviewed complaints on the provision of public services (including on the number of satisfied and dissatisfied complaints); - reports on the results of eliminating redundant requirements and improving administrative procedures in providing civil servants; - information on the results of the monitoring of public services, including monitoring data conducted in accordance with decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of December 12, 2012 N 1284. | 3. On the Foiv website, there are reports submitted by Foiv President and to the Russian government. | 3. The final report and the expert co-report on the results of the activity of FOOV for the reporting period are published on the FOB website and are considered at the final board. | 0 - no; 0.5 - for each of the listed positions. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. Plans and indicators of FOB activities, as well as reports and reports to the President and to the Russian government are presented in formats that are convenient for downloading from the site and if possible in the format of open data. | 4. The reporting information is accompanied by the views and analytical conclusions of the FOB manual, is subject to the long-term prospects for FOOV. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 4. The FOOV website hosts up-to-date information containing information on the results of checks in the Foiv, its territories and subordinating organizations, including: - a list and results of checks conducted - protocols (acts) of inspections, information on eliminating violations on the results of inspections. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. The FOB website contains government assignments and reports on their execution by federal budget and federal official institutions in the manner prescribed by the Government Decree of 02.09.2010 N 671. | 5. FOOV prepares a final report for the reporting period, including, including the following information: - a report on the implementation of the five-year plan of activity and the public declaration of goals and objectives in the context of the indicators achieved during the reporting period; - Report on the results of public discussion and expert support of the five-year plan of activity; - information on the activities of OS, expert and consulting councils with Foiv - a report on the forage of public procurement for the reporting period - a report on the effectiveness of the distributed allocations of the federal budget administered by the FOOV, in the context of the planned areas - a report on the implementation of control and supervisory functions - information about events Fores implemented in the field of competition, innovation, support for small and medium businesses. | 5. The system of personnel responsibility for the prevention of public control has been developed and implemented. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | Informing about working with the appeals of citizens and organizations | 1. Forms and periodically published on the site Foiv Reviews of the appeals of citizens, representatives of organizations (legal entities), public associations, including generalized information on the results of the consideration of received appeals and measures taken according to them. | 1. Created and constantly updated the section on the official Foive website, which hosts answers to the most frequently specified questions and complaints. | 1. A web service has been implemented that provides an automatic notification of receiving and registering or requesting an electronic form. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. In accordance with the law N 8-FZ on the FOOV website, information on officials responsible for the Foiv for working with the appeals of citizens, representatives of organizations (legal entities), public associations is posted. | 2. The results of the work of the FOOV with appeals and requests for information of citizens and legal entities is discussed at the Foiv meetings (meetings of the board), etc. | 2. It is running an online service tracking service and requests in the structural divisions of the FOOV. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. In accordance with the Government Decree of August 16, 2012, N 840 appointed authorized employees responsible for considering pre-trial complaints about the provision of public services in Foiv. | 3. Performance indicators of the timing of the direction of responses to the appeals and requests of citizens are included in the performance evaluation indicators structural units Foiv. | 3. Public discussion is held and independent score Work efficiency with appeals and requests for citizens' information, representatives of organizations (legal entities), public associations. The results of the assessment are posted on the FOB website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. In accordance with the Government Decree of August 16, 2012, N 840 is organized informing and advising the applicants on the procedure for pre-trial appeal in providing civil service, incl. The telephone numbers, email addresses, equipped with complaints of the complainants of the State Service, determined the procedure for appealing on a personal reception at the Foiv leadership. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 4. The mechanism of selective analysis was introduced by the Public Council, expert and advisory bodies with the forage of the quality of responses to the appeal of citizens, representatives of organizations (legal entities), public associations. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 4. Forms and published on the official website FOOV report on the adopted organizational and administrative measures aimed at improving the quality of work with appeals and demands of citizens and legal entities. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. On the FOB website, the phone number is specified by which you can get reference information, incl. For the provision of public services. | 5. Created public reception foiv. | 5. In the direction of response to appeal to the applicant, it seems to him a link to the service with the questionnaire to evaluate the work of the FOOV with the appeals and requests of citizens, representatives of organizations (legal entities), public associations. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | Organization of work with reference groups of the federal executive authority | 1. Reference groups focused on the activities of the FOOV, the procedure for interaction with them the structural divisions of FOOV is posted on the Foiv website. | 1. Created an open base (list) of experts in the field of public administration in different spheres of the powers of Foiv. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 1. For different reference groups, expert and consultative bodies, with Foiv, specialized forms and methods of interaction, taking into account interests and expectations of interested groups, have been created. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. Approved provisions on expert and consultative bodies with Foiv, determined the procedure for selecting candidates for their members. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 2. A system of address mailings was created by experts, representatives of reference groups with their invitation to participate in public discussions of the initiatives and solutions of FOOV. | 2. The system of motivation and promotion of the activities of the most active experts, representatives of reference groups have been developed and implemented. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. Approved plans for the work of expert and advisory bodies with Foiv. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 3. The results of interaction with reference groups in the form of decorated proposals, changes and additions to regulations Regularly discussed with the Public Council and, if necessary, are included in the work plans. | 3. Reference groups are evaluating the effectiveness and effectiveness of public discussions and public consultations on the main activities, the results are posted on the Foiv website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. In the list of bodies and organizations that are sent to operational information on the start of public discussion on the website regulation.gov.ru NPU projects in accordance with the rules of the decision N 851, reference groups, expert and advisory bodies with Foiv are included. | 4. Approved additional forms of full-time public consultation and public discusses in Foiv with reference groups, expert and advisory bodies of the most socially significant NAP projects, in addition to the requirements of the Resolution N 851. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 4. Approved procedures for conducting operational, incl. Online, public discusses and various forms of public consultation with reference groups, expert and advisory bodies with the Foiv on projects and the initiatives of the department. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. The FOOV website hosts consolidated information on the results of public discussion of NAP projects on the official website Regulation.gov.ru and the results of the adoption of a particular act with an explanation of the accounting (not accounting) received during the public discussion of proposals. | 5. Developed and included in the system of evaluating the effectiveness of the activities of the FOB (its structural divisions) by the evaluation of reference groups, members of the expert and advisory bodies of the results of the work of the FOOV, its structural divisions, terorganov. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 5. FOOV holds a periodic assessment of the quality of services and information channels created for feedback (interaction) with different reference groups, members of expert and advisory bodies. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 1. Approved the Regulations on the Public Council, which takes into account the main norms of the approximate position on the OS. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 1. The OS work plan is formed taking into account the proposals of the reference groups, is posted on the FOB website at the beginning of the calendar year or during the quarter after the formation of a new composition of the OS. | 1. There is an independent expert assessment of the effectiveness of the interaction of FOOV from the OS, the results of this assessment are published on the FOB website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. The personal composition of the OS was approved, in its composition - representatives of different reference groups. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 2. On the Foive website, the OS work plan is placed, including incl. Consideration: - annual reports of the head of the FOOV on key areas of activity of FOOV, public declarations / FOOP plans until 2018, - reports on the results of monitoring and supervisory activities and (or) reports on the results of monitoring the provision of civil servation; - the results of the introduction of other mechanisms (tools) of openness. | 2. OS according to the approved folding methodology conducts an assessment of the activities of the FOOV. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 0.5 - for each of the listed positions. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. The OS examines and gives conclusions to the works developed by the Fore projects and documents in accordance with the Decisions of the Government of the Russian Federation of September 1, 2012 N 877, of March 30, 2013 N 286, of April 30, 2013 N 382 and other solutions President and Russian Government. | 3. OS in accordance with established order Considers the results of public discussions of NPU projects and FOB reports. Information if necessary is posted on the Foiv website. | 3. Created discovered discussion platforms, incl. On the Internet, to discuss proposals and the conclusions of the OS on the Fores developed by the projects of NPA, documents and initiatives. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. The decisions and conclusion accepted on the projects under consideration and initiatives are posted on the FOB website regardless of the decisions taken by the FOOV. | 4. Approved and posted on the site Foiv procedure for the inclusion of interested experts in working groups (commission), created within the framework of the OS work. | 4. OS meetings are in open mode, with the invitation of media representatives, reference groups and citizens. The Foive website has the procedure for participation in open OS meetings. The place and time of the meetings are announced in advance. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. On the FOB website, a special section was created (page) dedicated to the operation of the OS. The section (page) is maintained up to date. | 5. A simplified order has been developed, incl. In shortened time, consideration of the turning requests for members of the OS members aimed at the Foiv decision by decision of the Council. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 5. On the FOB website for OS members, specialized " Personal cabinets", incl. For authorized access to FOB services, if necessary. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | The work of the press service of the federal executive authority | 1. Approved and published goals, objectives, structure and functions of the press service in accordance with the specifics of the activity of the FOOV. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 1. The list of communication channels (communication strategies) with different reference groups is determined. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 1. Trainings (training) are held for employees for the organization of communicating with the media and on the use of social networks. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. Approved the provision (procedure, regulation) on the interaction of structural divisions of the FOOV in the preparation of answers to the requests for media editor requests, providing comments, organization of interviews with the leadership of the Foiv, etc. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 2. For journalists, sending notifications about events and invitations for events (press releases and press announcements). | 2. It is possible to carry out online chat on social networks with a consultant - Foiv employee. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. On the FOB website, a section was created by an interview with the FOOV guidance, news, press releases on the activities of FOOV, video recording of official events with the participation of FOOV managers. | 3. Shares (media apartments) are held on the clarification of the objectives and tasks of FOB. | 3. Removed and posted on the FOB website and in social networks videos to advocate key areas of activity FOOV. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 4. Developed a development strategy (concept, plan) of the work of FOOV with social networks. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 4. Official Internet representation of FOOV has been created in mass common and professional social networks. On the FOB website linked to social networks (banners). | 4. FOOV conducts an assessment of the demand of different categories of media information and social networks. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. The monitoring of the media is carried out with the established frequency. | 5. Measurement of the frequency of appeals (attendance) to the materials posted on the FOB website is carried out. | 5. Developed indicators that assess the work of the FOB (or its structural divisions) on the coverage of their activities on the site, in the press, social networks. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 1. In Foiv at least once a quarter, consideration of law enforcement practices on the results of the courts entered into legal force, arbitration courts On the recognition of invalid abnormative legal acts, illegal decisions and actions (inaction) of these bodies, organizations and their officials in order to develop and adopt measures to prevent and eliminate the causes of identified disorders. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 1. On the site, FOOV in the "Anti-Corruption Expertise" subsection, prompt and analytical information on the results of the anti-corruption expertise of NAP projects were submitted to the position of the FOOV in corruption factors identified during the examination. | 1. On the FOB website, it is possible to view the results of anti-corruption examination on NPA projects for previous periods. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 2. On the Foiv website there is a program (plan) of opposition to corruption and the course of its execution in Foiv. | 2. The practice of preparing the final summary reports on the results of anti-corruption examination, in which the Foiv sets out its position in all corruption factors identified during the examination. | 2. Organized anti-corruption examination of previously accepted NAPs, law enforcement practice is considered by reference groups and at the OS meetings. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 3. In the Foiv adopted (approved) the Code of Ethics and the official behavior of Foiv employees. Information is posted on the Foiv website. | 3. For civil servants, a training course is conducted for the development of the Ethics Code. | 3. Specialized advanced training of FOOB staff involved in the development of NAP projects, conducting inspections and providing civil servants, on competencies of anti-corruption behavior. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 4. The FOB website publishes information about income, expenses, property and liabilities. property Character civil servants in accordance with Russian legislation. | 4. Information on income, expenses, property and property obligations are located: 1) in a unified form, 2) for all reporting periods, 3) without limiting the placement period on the site, 4) without limiting access to third parties. | 4. On the FOB website published information (protocols) on meetings of the Commission for Compliance with the requirements for service behavior and resolving the conflict of interests and decisions taken on them. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 5. Feedback is organized for the facts of corruption with the use of a selected phone number, email | 5. Installed the order of the "hotline" phone to receive reports of citizens and legal entities on the facts of corruption in Foiv. | 5. In the framework of the section with reference information, a section was created for monitoring law enforcement practices: Citizens describe controversial precedents from the scope of Foiv, and Foiv prepares the appropriate comments. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the link to the official site of FOOV is indicated. | 0 - no; 1 - yes, partly; 2 - yes. If necessary, the reference to the official site of FOOV |
Appendix N 2.
to the method of monitoring and evaluation
Openness of federal bodies
executive power
INDICATORS
Performance of implementation of mechanisms (tools)
Openness and statistical indicators,
Used to calculate them
Adopted in the text abbreviation
| Mechanism (tool) | Performance indicator | Statistical indicators for calculating performance indicators | Realization of the principle of information openness FOOV | 1. The share of services created on the FOB website to involve citizens and public associations in the development and decision-making of FOOV, to the total number of services of the official site of FOOV. | 1.1. The total number of special services created on the site. 1.2. The number of serves of the FOOV, created in the interests of citizens, including: - information (obtaining information from FOB), mobile, interactive or dialogue (including assessment), - reference and training, - electronic public services. | 2. The share of users who are satisfied with the quality of search and obtain the required information, behind which they appealed to the official site of the FOOV. | Survey data conducted on the FOB website, with established frequency. | Providing work with open data | 3. The proportion of data sets placed in machine-readable format (two or three stars by classification of data formats), as a percentage. | The total number of data sets, from them: - in PDF - in Excel / CSV - in XML / JSON - in RDF / OWL with access via API. | 4. Total downloads for each set of open data, mean value. | The total number of downloads for each set of open data, for the quarter, for the year. | Providing the comprehension of regulatory regulation, government policies and programs developed (implemented) | 5. The proportion of projects of regulatory legal acts, with a public discussion of which technologies were used to ensure the comprehension of regulatory regulation. | 5.1. The number of NAP projects undergoing public discussion procedures in accordance with, for the quarter, for the year. 5.2. The number of NAP projects outlined on the FOB website using technologies to ensure the comprehension of regulatory regulation. | 6. The share of visits to the sections of the site Foiv, which hosts NAP projects using technologies to ensure the comprehensiveness of regulatory regulation, to the total number of visitors to the site, for the quarter, per year, percentage. | 6.1. Total number of visits to the site Foiv, for the quarter, for the year 6.2. Number of visits to the sections of the site FOOV, which contains NAP projects using technologies to ensure the comprehension of regulatory regulation, to the total number of visitors to the site, for the quarter, for the year. | Work with the appeals of citizens and organizations | 7. The proportion of the appeals of citizens considered by Foiv in set time, To the total number of citizens' appeals received in the forage, per year, in percent. | 7.1. The total number of conversion of citizens enrolled in Foiv, during the reporting period. 7.2. The number of appeals of citizens reviewed by the FOOV within the prescribed period. | 8. The proportion of conversion of citizens enrolled in the flood in electronic form, to the total number of citizens' appeals received for the year, percentage. | 8.1. The total number of appeals of citizens enrolled in Foiv, for the year. 8.2. The number of conversion of citizens enrolled in the flood in electronic form for the year. | Work with reference groups, expert and advisory bodies | 9. The share of documents participating in public discussions, plans and other documents of reference groups on the number of reveal reference groups of FOOV, as a percentage. | 9.1. The number of reveal reference groups of FOOV. 9.2. The number of reference groups that Foive attracts to public discussion of draft regulatory legal acts of participating in public discussions on various types of documents and solutions, mean value. | 10. The proportion of NAP projects for which offers from reference groups on the results of public discussion in accordance with decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 25, 2012 N 851 , in percents. | 10.1. NGA projects undergoing public discussion procedures in accordance with decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 25, 2012 N 851 , for the quarter, for the year. 10.2. The number of draft regulatory legal acts on which within the framework of public discussion on the official website regulation.gov.ru on the Internet "Internet", bodies and organizations from the reference groups of FOOV presented a prescribed period in electronic or writing their proposals on the results of public discussion, for the quarter , per year. | Foiv interaction with the Public Council | 11. The proportion of socially significant projects (documents) developed by the Foiv and received a positive conclusion of the Public Council, to the total number of projects developed by the project (documents), as a percentage of the documents under consideration. | 11.1. The number of projects (documents) developed by the freight during the year (six months), of which publicly meaningful: NPU projects, which are included in the draft law of the Government of the Russian Federation for the next year; NPA projects developed by the Foil on the basis of solutions of the expert working group of the federal level on the results of the consideration of public initiatives sent by citizens of the Russian Federation using the Internet resource "Russian Public Initiative"; NPU projects that are established public regulations are determined by the size of public regulations and (or) the procedure for their indexation is established, as well as the procedure for executing public regulations, and changes to them; projects state programs The Russian Federation developed by the FOOB in accordance with the procedure for the development, implementation and evaluation of the effectiveness of state programs of the Russian Federation, approved, with the exception of federal targeted programs containing information related to state secret, or confidential information, and changes to them; NPA projects developed by Foiv, a preliminary discussion of which at meetings of public councils with these FOOV is provided for by the decision of the Government of the Russian Federation, and changes to them. 11.2. The number of socially significant projects (documents) developed by Foiv during the year (six months) and received a positive conclusion of the Public Council when considering: NPU projects, which are included in the draft law of the Government of the Russian Federation for the next year; NPA projects developed by the Foil on the basis of solutions of the expert working group of the federal level on the results of the consideration of public initiatives sent by citizens of the Russian Federation using the Internet resource "Russian Public Initiative"; NPU projects that are established public regulations are determined by the size of public regulations and (or) the procedure for their indexation is established, as well as the procedure for executing public regulations, and changes to them; Projects of state programs of the Russian Federation developed by the FOOV in accordance with the procedure for developing, implementing and evaluating the effectiveness of government programs of the Russian Federation approved decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 2, 2010 N 588 , with the exception of government programs of the Russian Federation, containing information related to state secrets, or confidential information, and changes to them; Projects of federal targeted programs developed by the FOB in accordance with the procedure for the development and implementation of federal targeted programs and interstate targeted programs, in the implementation of which the Russian Federation is involved decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of June 26, 1995 N 594 , with the exception of federal targeted programs containing information related to state secrets, or confidential information, and changes to them; NPA projects developed by Foiv, a preliminary discussion of which at meetings of public councils with these FOOV is provided for by the decision of the Government of the Russian Federation, and changes to them. | 12. The proportion of issues discussed during the reporting period at meetings of the Public Council at the open mode in open mode, with the invitation of media representatives, reference groups and citizens, incl. With the use of Internet broadcast, in percent. | 12.1. The number of issues discussed during the reporting period at the meetings of the Public Council at Foiv. 12.2. Of these, the number of issues discussed at the meetings of the Public Council in open mode, with the invitation of media representatives, reference groups and citizens is open, incl. using Internet broadcast. | Work press service FOOV | 13. The share of media requests, the response to which FOB provides in a shortened time limit (less than 7 days established by law), for the quarter, for the year. | 13.1. The number of queries coming from the media in Foiv for the quarter for the year. 13.2. The number of queries from the media, the answer to which the FOB provides in a shortened time limit (less than 7 days established by the legislation), for the quarter, for the year. | 14. The share of news (informational reasons), which were discussed in social media, to the total number of news posted on the official FOB website, in percent. | 14.1. The total number of news (informational reasons) posted on the official website for the quarter, for the year. 14.2. The number of news (information reasons), which were discussed in social media, incl. Facebook, Twitter, Vkontakte, Other. | Independent anti-corruption expertise and public monitoring of law enforcement | 15. The proportion of NPA projects for which anti-corruption expertise with a positive conclusion, to the total number of NPA projects undergoing public discussion procedures in accordance with decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 25, 2012 N 851 , for the quarter, for the year, percentage. | 15.1. NGA projects undergoing public discussion procedures in accordance with decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 25, 2012 N 851 , for the quarter, for the year. 15.2. NGA projects undergoing public discussion procedures in accordance with decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 25, 2012 N 851 For which anti-corruption examination is presented, from them with a positive conclusion, for the quarter, for the year. | 16. The proportion of NPA, which is held by public monitoring of law enforcement, to the total number of NPA projects, on which proposals are received from reference groups on the results of public discussion in accordance with decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of August 25, 2012 N 851 , in percents. | 16.1. The number of NAP projects for which within the framework of public discussion on the official website regulation.gov.ru on the Internet "Internet", organs and organizations from the reference groups of FOOV submitted within the established period in electronic or writing their proposals on the results of public discussion, for the quarter, per year. 16.2. The number of NAPs by which public monitoring of law enforcement is carried out. |